Remove this ad

avatar

quasar

Seasoned Member

Posts: 3,360

Lead

Jul 3 11 7:26 AM

Tags : :

In Retrospect: Myths About Israel and Palestine

by Dr. Thomas Ice -

The top story in the media has been the ongoing saga of the so-called "peace process" between Israel and the Arabs, popularly known as "Palestinians." This, of course, is not surprising to those of us who take a literal view of Bible prophecy, since Israel is at the center of imminent future events. However, I am constantly annoyed by the steady stream of myths and propaganda that streams from the global media, often misinforming the world about the modern land of Israel. This month I want to demythologize a number of popular notions about the Land of Israel, so that prophecy-loving believers may not be taken in by what they hear and see in today's media.

 The Ancient Palestinians

Perhaps the most maddening term that I hear today is related to the term "Palestinian." Let me start by providing a history of that word. It was a term invented by the Roman Emperor Hadrian in a.d. 135 after he had destroyed Jerusalem during a campaign to put down a Jewish uprising known as the Bar Kokhba revolt. Hadrian was tired of the constant revolts by the Jews in the land of Israel so he set out to "de-Judaize" Israel. This he did by renaming Jerusalem Aelia Capitolina and he renamed the Land of Israel Palestine from the word Philistine, a reference to the ancient Canaanites. Palestine became the common term that many used to refer to the biblical land of Israel. During the early 1900s and before 1948, a Palestinian was always thought to be a Jew who lived in the land of Israel, of course, popularly known as Palestine. When Israel became a nation in 1948, the Jews took the biblical term Israel to refer to the reborn nation. Some time between 1948 and 1963, the Egyptian, Yasser Arafat took the term Palestine to refer to the Arab claim of the land of Israel. Thus, it was only around 1963 that the term Palestinian began to be used of Arabs. There is no such thing as the ancient land of Palestine. It is the ancient land of Israel.  Because of the contemporary use of the term "Palestine," I think it is best that Christians refrain from using it to refer to the land of Israel. This is how Israel is usually referred to, even in biblical maps from the time of Christ and before, when the term was not invented until 100 years after the time of Christ. This is why in our newly produced Tim LaHaye Prophecy Study Bible we insisted upon using the term "Israel" when referencing the land of Israel. We did not call it Palestine. The only real Palestine I know of is a town in East Texas with that name.

 The Palestinian Right of Return

In light of what I noted in the previous section, it follows that the so-called Palestinian "right of return" is a key element in Arafat's position in the Oslo Peace Process. This is one of the few issues that current Israeli Prime Minister Ehud Barak has not caved in on, . . . at least not yet. Arafat claims that there are about four million Arabs and their descendants who were displaced by Israel in 1948. This is a most ridiculous claim. First of all, only about 200,000 Arabs left their homes in the land of Israel.[1] Few, if any, of these Arabs "refugees" were forced out by the Israelis. Instead, "The Arab refugees were not driven from Palestine by anyone," notes Samuel Katz. "The vast majority left, whether of their own free will or at the orders or exhortations of their leaders, always wit the same reassurance-that their departure would help in the war against Israel."[2]  After the 1948 war, Arab leaders refused to settle these refugees, even though hundreds of thousands of Jews were expelled from Arab lands with only the shirt on their backs.[3] In fact, based upon conservative estimates, at least two times more Jews were made refugees from the countries in which they lived and have now been settled in the land of Israel without the need for refugee camps that the Arabs are so famous for constructing for their people. Lately, Arafat has been demanding four to five billion dollars as reparations for the so-called "Palestinian refugees," while no one has brought up the fact that the Jews left behind in their country of origin billions of dollars worth of property. Where is the outcry for Jewish compensation?  Instead of settling Arabs who left Israel in 1948 in other Arab countries, Arab leaders have consistently insisted that they remain huddled together in the squalor of refugee camps in various locations throughout the Middle East. Joan Peters noted in 1984:  Over the last thirty-odd year, numerous projects have been proposed, international funds provided, studies undertaken, all indicating the benefits that could be derived by the Arab refugee from their absorption into the brethren cultures of the Arab host countries.[4]  Yet Arab leaders always reject any solution that might serve to solve the problem. Even though the Arab refugees number only in the hundreds of thousands, others have successfully exchanged many times that number. Peters notes that, "The exchange between India and Pakistan in the 1950s was overwhelming in magnitude: 8,500,000 Sikhs and Hindus from Pakistan fled to India, and roughly 6,500,000 Muslims moved from India to Pakistan."[5] The fact that "from 1933 to 1945, a total of 79,200,000 souls were displaced," is staggering. But all but the Arab refugees from Israel have not been able to find a place of settlement. Why? Because the long-term Arab goal is not peaceful co-existence with Israel, but a total annihilation of every Jew and the modern nation of Israel. This reality is why it is foolish for Israel to continue the Oslo Peace Process.

 David and Goliath

During the so-called "Temple Mount Intifada" we have seen a blatant example of Arab manipulation of the media in the incident of the death of the twelve-year old Arab boy named Mohammed. The world's media captured the sad death of Mohammed in a crossfire between Arabs and Israelis. The video footage revealed the boy being shot and dying in his father's arms. The immediate outcry from the global media was how the evil Israelis (the bully Goliath) were picking on the poor defenseless Arabs (David). The media assumed and then reported that Mohammed was shot by the Israeli army. Few asked what the boy was doing there in the first place. Few noted that Mohammed's father had come to get him because he had gone to throw rocks at the Israeli army. But, most significantly, it was reported in the alternative media that there were questions about whether the Israelis were even in position to have shot the boy. A later investigation has proved that it was impossible for the Israeli soldiers to have shot him since they could not have hit him since they were not in position to have the right angle to get to him. It is now clear that the Arabs shot one of their own, apparently for propaganda purposes. They cared more about sending out to the global media a certain image than they did about the life of that twelve-year old boy. This kind of thing is all too common in the battle for truth in the propaganda wars coming out of Israel in our day. In fact, established reports have revealed that the Saudi Arabian government is paying $2,000.00 to the family members of each Arab killed in the current Intifada and $300.00 for each non-fatal wound. This is most revealing when one realizes that Muslims believe that they are guaranteed to go to heaven if they die during the current conflict. Boy are they in for an immediate surprise. This is probably the most blatant propaganda piece of the entire conflict.

 The Temple Mount

Another classic instance of Arab lying that has come out in the media recently is their widely held belief that there has never been a Jewish Temple upon the Temple Mount (Arabs call it Al-Qods-Al-Sharif) in Jerusalem. Randall Price and I noted this in our book, Ready To Rebuild, in the early 1990s. This belief, coupled with the equally errant lie, that the place of Mohammed's supposed ascent into heaven occurred on the Temple Mount in Jerusalem. This was a later myth added to the lore of Islam as time went on and they became engaged in a rivalry with Christianity and Judaism, both of whom had a rich history of events that transpired in Jerusalem. Islam had none.  The question arises that if there never was a Jewish Temple upon the Temple Mount, then where did Jesus walk in New Testament times? What a crook! There is more historical and archaeological evidence supporting the historicity of the Bible's report that there were two Jewish Temples upon the Temple Mount in Jerusalem than is needed to accept any fact of antiquity. Yet, this does not seem to phase the Muslim faithful. If there was no Temple upon the Temple Mount then what did Josephus write about when he records the destruction of the Jewish Temple in a.d. 70. This kind of outright lying is revealing about the whole Islamic religion: It does not care about the truth, only propaganda. Thus, we should not be surprised, I am not, at the lengths to which too many Arabs will go in our own day as they spin Middle Eastern events to the global media. But, as lovers of the truth, Christians should not fall for these Arab distortions.

 Conclusion

As believers in God and His Word, we should not be surprised that Satan and the world system is anti-Israel. We should also not be surprised that in spite of the justness of Israel's cause that the international media echoes Satan's voice, instead of God's. Israel is God's elect nation and He works out a major aspect of His plan for history through them. Therefore, the least that believers should do is not be taken in by the myths and propaganda from the world's media. To help towards this end I want to recommend some excellent books that will provide an interested person with factual information.

In spite of all the current bias against Israel we know what the end of the matter will be. Yes, Israel will exist for all eternity, while he enemies will be judged at Armageddon. It helps in the present time to know the God who has told us the end from the beginning. Maranatha!


Quasar 

Quote    Reply   
Remove this ad
Remove this ad
avatar

beloved

Senior Member

Posts: 245

#1 [url]

Oct 1 11 5:21 AM

Quasar, thank you for that article. I believe not many know the history of Israel and the origin of the "word" Palestine. IMO This  information should be visible where the truth can be shown. I took the liberty and   added bold and underline in some areas. Quote from the above article:

In Retrospect: Myths About Israel and Palestine  by Dr. Thomas Ice - The top story in the media has been the ongoing saga of the so-called "peace process" between Israel and the Arabs, popularly known as "Palestinians." This, of course, is not surprising to those of us who take a literal view of Bible prophecy, since Israel is at the center of imminent future events. However, I am constantly annoyed by the steady stream of myths and propaganda that streams from the global media, often misinforming the world about the modern land of Israel. This month I want to demythologize a number of popular notions about the Land of Israel, so that prophecy-loving believers may not be taken in by what they hear and see in today's media.
 The Ancient Palestinians
Perhaps the most maddening term that I hear today is related to the term "Palestinian." Let me start by providing a history of that word. It was a term invented by the Roman Emperor Hadrian in a.d. 135 after he had destroyed Jerusalem during a campaign to put down a Jewish uprising known as the Bar Kokhba revolt. Hadrian was tired of the constant revolts by the Jews in the land of Israel so he set out to "de-Judaize" Israel. This he did by renaming Jerusalem Aelia Capitolina and he renamed the Land of Israel Palestine from the word Philistine, a reference to the ancient Canaanites. Palestine became the common term that many used to refer to the biblical land of Israel.

During the early 1900s and before 1948, a Palestinian was always thought to be a Jew who lived in the land of Israel, of course, popularly known as Palestine. When Israel became a nation in 1948, the Jews took the biblical term Israel to refer to the reborn nation. Some time between 1948 and 1963, the Egyptian, Yasser Arafat took the term Palestine to refer to the Arab claim of the land of Israel. Thus, it was only around 1963 that the term Palestinian began to be used of Arabs. There is no such thing as the ancient land of Palestine. It is the ancient land of Israel.  Because of the contemporary use of the term "Palestine," I think it is best that Christians refrain from using it to refer to the land of Israel. This is how Israel is usually referred to, even in biblical maps from the time of Christ and before, when the term was not invented until 100 years after the time of Christ. This is why in our newly produced Tim LaHaye Prophecy Study Bible we insisted upon using the term "Israel" when referencing the land of Israel. We did not call it Palestine. The only real Palestine I know of is a town in East Texas with that name." END OF QUOTE

Satan has done a great job of trying to completely erase God's Israel from the map, the same as he tried to (and is still trying) erase God's Son Jesus and causing conflict among Christians concerning the Bible, the Word of God! The emerging Church and the seeker friendly Church seem to be this century's thrust.

From a Cal Thomas article:
"The world -- or at least the large part of it that hates Israel and wishes it would go away -- moves a step nearer that goal this week when the United Nations votes on whether to recognize a Palestinian state. The vote violates the Declaration of Principles signed by the PLO in 1993, which committed the terrorist group and precursor to the Palestinian Authority to direct negotiations with Israel over a future state. This violation is further evidence the Palestinian side cannot be trusted to live up to signed agreements and promises.
The Palestinians could have peace any time they wish and probably a state, too, if they acknowledged Israel's right to exist and practiced verbal, religious and military disarmament. One has a right to question the veracity of a people who claim they want peace, while remaining active in ideological, theological and military warfare aimed at its publicly stated objective: the eradication of the Jewish state."
http://jewishworldreview.com/cols/thomas092011.php3

We do know what will ultimately happen and we are told in the New Testament that we are to pray for Israel. I wonder how many Christians do that? I know I forget at times. When the Lord tells us to follow His commands how dare we forget this one?

This may not pertain to myths about Israel and Palestine but I think it is pertinent concerning knowledge about Israel and what this tiny nation has contributed to people all over the world. Including their enemies.

http://www.israel21c.org/didyouknow/didyouknow







 

Romans 1:17, For in the gospel a righteousness from God is revealed, a righteousness that is by faith from first to last, just as it is written:"The righteous will live by faith."

Quote    Reply   
avatar

beloved

Senior Member

Posts: 245

#3 [url]

Apr 22 13 12:51 PM

Video on Islam, Palestine and Jews. I didn't start a new topic and I thought it would be informative to revisit this page. I had seen this video before and when I went to visit the Berean Call to get information on the death of Dave Hunt it was on the list to the right.
    
 I hear, and see,  so much misinformation on the Jews stealing land from the Palestine people. That includes my son, whom I told to look up the information rather than listening to his liberal friends in Hollywood. At least he isn't a denier of the almost extermination of the Jews!!
   
 IMO, we must be knowledgeable in the defense of Israel.The video is long but well worth listening to and bookmarking

feature=plcp



Romans 1:17, For in the gospel a righteousness from God is revealed, a righteousness that is by faith from first to last, just as it is written:"The righteous will live by faith."

Quote    Reply   
Remove this ad
avatar

quasar

Seasoned Member

Posts: 3,360

#4 [url]

Apr 23 13 4:55 AM

By all means!  I have supported Jews for Jesus for more than 30 years as well as His Chosen People Ministries for about 10.  They are undeed in for some terrible times.  

When the six day war was going on, I listened on the radio as I worked my territory by car, covering three states, and I'm here to testify, God was with Israel without a shadow of a doubt, as they tore up Egypt, Jordan and Syria, when they took Jerusalem.

Not sure I read your remark re starting threads, which you are entitled to do any time you care to do so.


Quasar 

Quote    Reply   
avatar

beloved

Senior Member

Posts: 245

#5 [url]

Apr 25 13 3:49 AM

By all means!  I have supported Jews for Jesus for more than 30 years as well as His Chosen People Ministries for about 10.  They are undeed in for some terrible times.  
When the six day war was going on, I listened on the radio as I worked my territory by car, covering three states, and I'm here to testify, God was with Israel without a shadow of a doubt, as they tore up Egypt, Jordan and Syria, when they took Jerusalem.
Not sure I read your remark re starting threads, which you are entitled to do any time you care to do so.

Quasar 

-quasar

Quasar, I didn't want to start a new thread on this same topic so added to what you had already written. That way we will have a more complete picture. Have a great weekend. I am doing well actually but had a small relapse of coughing for 3 days. whew, I am tired of those but I am 90% better so you may see more of me. Except for weekends which seems to be house cleaning and picking up because of sloppy men. *G* Gene loves to work in the yard but he "forgets" to put away shovels, rakes, etc and we look like we are having a yard sale on tools!!!

Romans 1:17, For in the gospel a righteousness from God is revealed, a righteousness that is by faith from first to last, just as it is written:"The righteous will live by faith."

Quote    Reply   
avatar

quasar

Seasoned Member

Posts: 3,360

#6 [url]

Apr 25 13 7:44 AM






Quasar, I didn't want to start a new thread on this same topic so added to what you had already written. That way we will have a more complete picture. [image]Have a great weekend. I am doing well actually but had a small relapse of coughing for 3 days. whew, I am tired of those but I am 90% better so you may see more of me. Except for weekends which seems to be house cleaning and picking up because of sloppy men. *G* Gene loves to work in the yard but he "forgets" to put away shovels, rakes, etc and we look like we are having a yard sale on tools!!!


-beloved






Good idea, I just didn't know quite what you had in mind, Beloved.  Are you still taking Seanol from Dr. Sinatra, and do you take any alternate source nutrient for pain control?  I have found Reduloxin to be pretty effective.  But it may take two or three months to be effective.

http://www.advancedbionutritionals.com/Products/Reduloxin.htm

I'm sure glad my yard work days have been over now for the past 13 years.  I don't envy you guys, as it got to be my job alone to care for front and back lawn on one third acre of land, with the sciatica I still have.

I never got around to comment on the loss of Dave Hunt, April 5th of this year.  He was one of my favorites and a real warrior for the Lord.

You have a wonderful weekend too, my dear friend.

Blessings,


Quasar


Quote    Reply   
Remove this ad
Add Reply

Quick Reply

bbcode help